Proceedings

Opportunistic Processing in Arguments

Download BibTeX Cite

Proceedings of the Seventh International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence. Natural Language. Pages 58-59.

© 1981 International Joint Conferences on Artificial Intelligence

Abstract

In two previous papers. we have proposed a part of a computational theory of argumentation, including representations for argument structure and rules for using those representations in understanding and in rebutting (Birnbaum et a/. (1980) and Flowers et a/. (I 98 I); related work includes Cohen (I 980)) . One property of the model which we emphasized is the way in which argument mechanisms and inferential memory can each help to direct the proce ss ing of the other. In particular, we presented examples in which inferential memory can uncover good rebuttals to an input as a side-effect of the processing that naturally goes on in trying to understand that input. When such opportunities for rebuttal are noticed during understanding, they render unnecessary the use of argument rules to find a response. since one has already been di scove red.

  1. Birnbaum. L.. Flowers, M ., and McGuire. R. 1980. Towards an AI model of argumentation. In Proceedings of the First A AA I Conference, Stanford. CA. pp. 313-315.
  2. Cohen. R. 1980. Understanding arguments . In Proceedings of the Third CSCSI/ SCE/0 Conference.
  3. Victoria. BC.
  4. Flowers. M .. McGuire. R .. and Birnbaum. L. 1981. Adversary arguments and the logic of personal attacks .
  5. In W. Lehnert and M . Ringle. eds .. Strategies for Natural Language Processing.
  6. Hayes-Roth, B .. and Hayes-Roth, F. 1979. A cognitive model of planning. In Cognitive Science, vol. 3. pp. 275-310.
  7. Hobbs . J . 1979. Conversation as planned behavior. In Proceedings of the Sixth /JCAI, Tokyo. Japan. pp . 390-396. IJCAI
  8. Schank. R. 1980. Language and memory. In Cognitive Science. vol. 4. pp . 243-284.
  9. Schank. R . 1981. Dynamic Memory: A Theory <1{ Learning in Computers and People. (Forthcoming) .

References were extracted automatically from the PDF and may contain errors.

Welcome Future Conferences AI Journal Division IJCAI Proceedings About IJCAI IJCAI Awards