Proceedings

Repairing Preference-Based Argumentation Frameworks

Download BibTeX Cite

Proceedings of the Twenty-First International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence. Pages 665-669.

© 2009 International Joint Conferences on Artificial Intelligence

Abstract

Argumentation is a reasoning model based on the construction and evaluation of arguments. Dung has proposed an abstract argumentation framework in which arguments are assumed to have the same strength. This assumption is unfortunately not realistic. Consequently, three main extensions of the framework have been proposed in the literature. The basic idea is that if an argument is stronger than its attacker, the attack fails. The aim of the paper is twofold: First, it shows that the three extensions of Dung framework may lead to unintended results. Second, it proposes a new approach that takes into account the strengths of arguments, and that ensures sound results. We start by presenting two minimal requirements that any preference-based argumentation framework should satisfy, namely the conflict-freeness of arguments extensions and the generalization of Dung’s framework. Inspired from works on handling inconsistency in knowledge bases, the proposed approach defines a binary relation on the powerset of arguments. The maximal elements of this relation represent the extensions of the new framework.Leila Bahia Amgoud, Srdjan Vesic

  1. [Amgoud and Cayrol, 2002a] L. Amgoud and C. Cayrol. In- ferring from inconsistency in preference-based argumenta- tion frameworks. J. of Automated Reasoning, 29 (2):125- 169, 2002.
  2. [Amgoud and Cayrol, 2002b] L. Amgoud and C. Cayrol. A reasoning model based on the production of acceptable arguments. Annals of Mathematics and Artificial Intelli- gence, 34:197-216, 2002.
  3. [Amgoud and Prade, 2009] L. Amgoud and H. Prade. Using arguments for making and explaining decisions. Artificial Intelligence J., 173:413-436, 2009.
  4. [Baroni and Giacomin, 2007] P. Baroni and M. Giacomin. On principle-based evaluation of extension-based argu- mentation semantics. Artificial Intelligence J., 171:675- 700, 2007.
  5. [Bench-Capon, 2003] T. J. M. Bench-Capon. Persua- sion in practical argument using value-based argumen- tation frameworks. Journal of Logic and Computation, 13(3):429-448, 2003.
  6. [Benferhat et al., 1993] S. Benferhat, D. Dubois, and H. Prade. Argumentative inference in uncertain and inconsistent knowledge bases. In Proc. of UAI'93, pages 411-419, 1993.
  7. [Besnard and Hunter, 2008] Ph. Besnard and A. Hunter. El- ements of Argumentation. MIT Press, 2008.
  8. [Brewka, 1989] G. Brewka. Preferred subtheories: An ex- tended logical framework for default reasoning. In Proc. of IJCAI-89, pages 1043-1048, 1989. IJCAI
  9. [Cayrol et al., 1993] C. Cayrol, V. Royer, and C. Saurel. Management of preferences in assumption-based reason- ing. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, 682:13-22, 1993.
  10. [Dung, 1995] P. M. Dung. On the acceptability of arguments and its fundamental role in nonmonotonic reasoning, logic programming and n-person games. Artificial Intelligence J., 77:321-357, 1995.
  11. [Gelfond and Son, 1997] M. Gelfond and T.C. Son. Priori- tized default theory. Lecture Notes in AI, 1471, 1997.
  12. [Modgil, 2009] S. Modgil. Reasoning about preferences in argumentation frameworks. Artificial Intelligence J., 2009.
  13. [Prakken and Sartor, 1997] H. Prakken and G. Sartor. Argument-based extended logic programming with de- feasible priorities. J. of Applied Non-Classical Logics, 7:25-75, 1997.
  14. [Simari and Loui, 1992] G.R. Simari and R.P. Loui. A math- ematical treatment of defeasible reasoning and its imple- mentation. Artificial Intelligence J., 53:125-157, 1992.

References were extracted automatically from the PDF and may contain errors.

Welcome Future Conferences AI Journal Division IJCAI Proceedings About IJCAI IJCAI Awards