Proceedings

Fifth Generation Computer Crime Law

Download BibTeX Cite

Proceedings of the Ninth International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence. General. Pages 1274-1277.

© 1985 International Joint Conferences on Artificial Intelligence

Abstract

A~.t~e ·~hock absorber" of social change, cr1m1nal law will serve to deal with the most troublesome results o[ the progress in artic ial intelligence and expert systems research ar1d aFplication s. We will have to redefine crimes aqainst the pe rs on , property, publ i c morility, and the public order. To do thi s wi ll require conside ra b le change in our s t anda r ds of culpability, computer p erformance, and the functions of pu nishment.

Full text extracted automatically from the PDF; figures, tables and equations may differ. The PDF is the version of record.

1. Theoretical problems

lve have succeeded in refuting theories of correction, not supplanting them. Retribution is generally considered primitive and irrational, though it seems slightly on the rise. Rehabilitation is increasingly seen as an unfulfilled dream. (Given the abject corruption of prison environments, this should come as little surprise .) Deterrence of those inclined to commit crimes is still argued in every jurisdiction trying to decide whether to abolish --- or reinstitute -­ the death penalty . The only re asonab ly clear observation is that in ca rceration incapacitates those who are so pun ished for the duration of their s ta y behind bars. (Unfortunately crimes wi thin prison, including computer crimes, are not at all without precedent.)

vle must, of course, declare certain behavior illegal even if none of our stra tegies seems particularly effecti ve. One purpose of the Yugoslavian Criminal Code is "to exercise educational influence on other people [than the offender] in order to deter them from committing criminal offenses; [and] to influence development of social morals and soc ial discipline among citizens." [Goldstein, Dershowitz, and Schwa rtz, Cri~inal La~ at 724.]

Hart states a similar educational goal for American criminal law:

"To declare the obligation of every competent person to comply with (1) those standards of behavior which a responsible individual should know are imposed by the condi ti ons of community life if the benef it s of community living are to be realized, and (2) those further obligations of conduct, specially declared by the legislature, which the individual either in fact knows or has good reason to know he is supposed to comply with, and to prevent violations of these basic obligations of good citizenship by providing for public condemnation of the violations and appropr iate treatment of the violators." [Hart , "The Aims of the Criminal Law," 23 Law and Contempo rary Problems 401, 440 (1958) in Go l ds tein, Dershowitz and Schwartz , id.]

2. Practica l resolutions

Undeterred by a lack of theory, much of the prac ti ce in computer crime punishment resembles the old football cheer , " hit 'em again harder, ha r de r." Statu tes calling for fines up to three times the property taken, enhancements of punishment for use of computers to commit other crimes, and special p rov isions for civil suits by crime victims have all been tried in recent computer crime laws.

As a former prosecu tor I have seen the increased bu reaucratization of criminal l aw. The p rocess is typified by high volume case processing , high premiums on rapid turnover of cases, and most consistently,increased p leas barga inin g . The paucity of cases of computer crime resulting in appeals underscores the universality of thi s trend.

Conclus i on

The fifth gene ration will act as a magnifying glass , showing even more clearly the difficu lties soc iety faces trying to predict what needs to be protected, from whom, from what, and how.

Welcome Future Conferences AI Journal Division IJCAI Proceedings About IJCAI IJCAI Awards