Proceedings

AI and Legal Reasoning

Download BibTeX Cite

Proceedings of the Ninth International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence. General. Pages 1254-1259.

© 1985 International Joint Conferences on Artificial Intelligence

Abstract

Thil paper prelelltl a IWDID&ry of the ~ of a panel to illuel 011 Al and lepl ,.,.,..lna. Tbe panel CODiilted of: Bdwina L. Rillland, Chair (UDivenity of Maaacbuaetts), Kevin D. Atbley (UDivenity of Maaachuaetts), Michael 0. Dyer (UCLA), Alme v.dL. Oardner (Stanford), L. Tbome McCarty (Rutpn), and Doa.ald A. WatenDan .(RAND). Amooa the illuea ~ by the panel were: 1. What are the characterlldca of the lepl domaln that make it llltereldq or ameoable to AI approechea - wbat Ia lpOCial about lt; 2. Tbe opeo·tatured oature of lep1 cooc:ep11 and the lmpllcati0111 thll bu for llliDa Al·tec:bniquea, eapeclaUy knowledp repre~CDtatioo; 3. Tbe c:omplemeatulty of rule-bued and c:ue-bued reuooiDa - bow cuea are uted, eapecla1ly wbea the rulea "ruo out"; 4. Tbe pervuive role of aoaloay lD lep1 reuonlna; S. Tbe lpOCial role played by bypotheticala lD the lepl domaln and bow bypc11 belp wlth arpmeatatioo and stratqlc cue plannina; 6. Tbe interleavllla of )lstlficatioo, aplanatioo, and arpmeatatioo; 7. How c:ommoo law tylteml can be leell to be systems wbich leuo from cuea; 8. Tbe apprcpriateoe. and feuibility of lllteßlaent aldl for practicina litlptors and otber lepl experts; 9. lmpllcati0111 for otber domailll - llte medldnethat use c:ue-bued ,.,.,..lna; 10. Methodoloaical and otber illuel. For each illue COillidered, the c:ommeats of the panellats are summarized.

  1. Albiey, K. D. (1984). "Reuonina by Analogy: A Survey of Selec:tecl AJ. Research with lmplicatiODJ for Legal Expert Systems". In Proceeding1 Firn Anltlllll Coriference tHJ Law and Tecllnology, Univenity of Houstoo, Houstoo TX. To be ioduded io a collectioo to be publilbecl by West Pub. Co. io 1985.
  2. Aupst, S. B. and Dyer, M. G. (1985). "Underltandina Analopet in Editorials." UCLA AI Lab Memo.
  3. Birnbaum, L. (1982). "Argument Molecules: A Functional Representatioo of Araument Struc:ture". In Proceeding1 AMI-82.
  4. Pithburgb, PA.
  5. leBessooet, C. G. (1984). CCUPS, TM Civil Code Legal ln/ormDtioft Proce~ling Syltem. Law and AI Projec:t, Louiliana State Law Institute, Batoo Roup, LA.
  6. Corbin, A. L. (1961). The 1udicial Proc:al Revilitecl. Yale Law JDUTMl 71, 195-201.
  7. Dyer, M. G., cl Flowers, M. (1984). "''oward Automatins Lepl Bxpertile." In Proceeding1 of tM Firlt Law and Tecllnology Coriference. Univenity of Houstoo, Houltoo, Texu.
  8. Flowers, M. {1982). "'n 8einJ Cootradictory". In Proceeding1 of AMI-82.
  9. Pittlburp, PA.
  10. Flowers, M. and Dyer, M. G. (1984). "Really Arpi.na with your Computer in Natural Languap." In Proceeding1 of NCC~.
  11. Lu Vegu.
  12. Flowers, M., McGuire, R. and Birnbaum, L., (1982). "Advenary Arauments and the Loaic of Penonal Attacks." In Lebnert and Rioale (ecll.) Strategk1 for Natural Lturg1111ge Proce~ling. LBA Prell, NI.
  13. Gardner, Anne v.dL. (1984). All AnificUil lnlelligence ApprDGCII to Legal RetutHiing. Doctoral Oillertatioo, Deputment of Computer Science, Stanford Univenity.
  14. --(1983). "The Dellp of a Lepl AnalytiJ Program." In Proceedillg1 AMI-83.
  15. Wublnatoo, DC.
  16. Goldman, S. R., Dyer, M. G. • and Flowers, M., (1985). "Prec:edence-Balecl Leaal Reuootna in Contract Law ." UCLA AI Lab Memo.
  17. Hobfeld, W. N. (1919). "Fundamental Lepl Cooceptions u Appliecl in 1udicial Rea.,.,lna." Yale U. Prell, New Haven, CT, Bd., W. W. Cook.
  18. Kubn, T. S. (1970). Tlle StrlletUre of Scknlf/ic Revoluttoru. Sec:ood Bditioo. Univenity of Cbicaao Prell.
  19. Lakat01, I. (1976). Proofs and Refutatiotu. Cambridge University Press, Londoo.
  20. Levi, E. H . (1949). An lntroduction to ugal Reasoning. University of Chicago Press.
  21. Llwellyn, K. N. (1930). The Bramble Bush. Ocean Publications.
  22. ----(1960). The Common Law Tradition: Deciding Appeals. Little Brown, BOiton.
  23. McCarty, L. T. (1983a). "Intelligent Legal Information Systems: Problems and Prospects." Rutgers Computer and Technology Law Journal 9(2):265-294. (1983b) "Permissions and Obligations." In Proceedings /JCA/-83.
  24. Karlsruhe, W. Gennany. (1977). "Reßections on TAXMAN: An Experiment in Artüicial Intelligence and Legal Reasoning." Harvard Law Revkw 90:831-93.
  25. McCarty, L. T. and Sridharan, N. S. (1981a). ~e Representation of an EvolvinJ System of Legal Coocepts: ll. Prototypes and Deformations." In Proceedings /JCA/-8/. (1981b). A Computational Theory of ugal ArgWMnl. Technical Report LRP-TR-13, Laboratory for Computer Science Research, Rutgers University.
  26. McGuire, R., Birnbaum, L., and Flowers, M. (1981). "Opportunistic Processi.ng in Arguments". In Proceedings /JCA/-81.
  27. Vancouver, B.C. Polya, G. (1973). lnduction and Analogy in Mathemlllics, Volumes 1 &: 2. Princeton University Press, New Jersey.
  28. Peterson, M. A . (1983). New Tools for Reducing Civil Litigation E:cpenses. Memo R-3013-ICI. The Institute for Civil Iustice, The RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, CA.
  29. Reichman, R. (1981). "Modeling Informal Debates". In Proceedings /JCA/-81.
  30. Vancouver, B.C., August.
  31. Rissland, E. L . (1984a). "Argument Moves and Hypotheticals". In Proceedings First Annual Conference 0r1 Law and Technology. University of Houston, Houston TX. To be included in a c:ollection to be publisbed by West Pub. Co. in 1985. (1981). E:cample Generation. Technical Report 81-24, Department of Computer and Information Science, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA. (1982). "Examples Hypotheticals in Contract Law". Annual Cognitive Science Society Michigan, Ann Arbor. in the Legal Domain: In Proceedings F ourth Conference. Univ. of ----(1983). "Examples in Legal lteuonins: Legal Hypotheticals". In Proceedings /JCA/-83. Karlsruhe, W. Gennany. ----(1984b). "Hypothetically Speaking: &perience and Reuooing in the Law". To appear in Cognitive Science. An earlier version appeared in Proceedings First Annual Conference Oft Theoretical /ssues in Conceptual lnformotion Processing, Georgia Tech, March. (1984c). ~e Ubiquitous Dialectic". In Proceedings Si:cth Ewopellll Conference 0r1 Artificiol lnlelligence (ECA/-84), held in Pisa, Italy, September, publisbed by Elsevier (North-Holland). (1978). "UnderstandinJ UnderstandinJ Mathematics". Cognilive Science, Vol. 2, No.
  32. Rissland, E. L., Valcarce, E. M., and Asbley, K. D. (1984). "Explaining and Arguing with Examples". In Proceedings AAAI-84, Austin, Texas.
  33. Waterman, D. A ., and Petenoo, M. A. (1981). Models of Legal Decision Making. Memo R-2717-ICI. The Institute for Civil Iustice, The RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, CA.

References were extracted automatically from the PDF and may contain errors.

Welcome Future Conferences AI Journal Division IJCAI Proceedings About IJCAI IJCAI Awards