Proceedings

Toward a Detailed Model of Processing for Language Describing the Physical World

Download BibTeX Cite

Proceedings of the Seventh International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence. Natural Language. Pages 1-5.

© 1981 International Joint Conferences on Artificial Intelligence

Abstract

This paper explores the problem of ju1ging wheth~r or not an English sentence could correspom to a real 'llorld situation or event which is is literally, physically plausible, and the relate~ problem of representi~ the different possible physical situ~tions. The judgement of plausibility can be made at a high level by checkisemantic marker restrictions on verb case fra~e constituents. Often, however, plausibility judgement can only be based on the results of an attempt to construct (imagine) a scene that corresponds to the sentence, and which does not violate "ccmmon sense" (i.e. relevant physical laws and expected, stereotype1 behavior). Methods are presented for constructing representations for different scenes which could correspond to a sentence. These methods incorporate (1) "subscripts" (sequences of scenes which ccmprise an event, with attachepreconditions and postconditions) to express different verb senses, (2) object representations which express properties such as shape, size, weight 1 strength, and behavior t.nder ccmmon conditions; (~I physic.'ll laws, encoded as constraints on behavior; (4) representation of context; and (5) robot problem solving-like methods to fit all this material together.

  1. the references below TINIAP-1 r'efers to R. Schank srrl B. Nash-webber (eds.~ Theoretical Iss~s in Nstur''il Lsnguage Processing, Arhngton, VA: ----xcr;;-W75;-anQ 'I'IINIAP-2 refers to D. Wsl tz ( ed.) Theoretic'il Issues in Natural IBng\13.ge Processing--2, New York: ACM, 1~-
  2. Boggess, L. c. 1979. Computstional Interpr'etation of English Spatial Prepositions. Tech Rpt T-7~. CSL, Univ. of Illinois.
  3. Brachman, R. J. 1979. CXl the Epistemological Status of Semantic Networks. In N. Findler (Ed.), Assocfslive Networks. New York: Acadootic.
  4. BUndy, A. 1978. Will It Reach the Top? Pred iction in the Mechanics World. Artifici'l.l Intelti1ence 10, 2.
  5. Chafe," W. L. 1979. 'l'ne flow of toought and the flow of lll!lg\13.ge. In T. Givon (Ed.) Discourse and Synt~'J New York: Academic.
  6. Colby, K., B. ~ught, and R. Parkinson. 1974. Psttern Matching Rules of the Recognition of Nstural Language Dialogue Ex:pressions. Memo AIM-234, Stanford AI Lab.
  7. Davis, R. 1978. Knowledge Aquisition in Rule-Bssed Systems. In D. Waterman and F. Hsy"ls-Roth (eds.) Psttern-directed Inference Systems. New York : Ac ademic.
  8. de Kleer, J. 1977. MUltiple Representations of Knowle:lge in a Mechanics Problem-solver. IJCAI-77, 197-2P3 L'31 Fillmore, C. J. 1977. 'l'ne Case for Case Reopened. In J. Kimball (Ed.) Syntax and Semantics. New York: Academic. - [
  9. ~1 Forbus, K. D. 1981. A Study of Qualitative and Geometric Knowledge in Reasoning about l'btion. Tech Rpt AI-TR-61 ~. MIT AI IB.b.
  10. Grice, H. P. 1975. Lo~ic 'l.nd Conversstion.
  11. In P. Cole and J. l'brgan (Eds.) Syntax m1 Semantics: Speecp ~ltsH New York: Academic.
  12. - -----r1 ayes, P. J. 1978. 'l'ne Naive Physics funif~sto; 'ind Nsive Physics 1: CX!tology for Liquids. Tech. Rpts., Institute for Semantic and Cognitive Studi~s, Geneva. L121 Herskovitz, A. 196). CXl the spatial uses of prepositions. Proc. of 18th Annual Meeting of the ACL, Univ. o~ Penn. ;t~iiTa. ------------ [n J Johnson-Laird, P. N. 1900. Mental models in cognitive science. Cognitive Science 4, 1, 71-115. [141
  13. McCarthy, J. 1968. Programs with common sense. In Sem:J.ntic Information Processing, M. Minsky ( eci.), MIT Press Cambri1ge, RA, 403=418. L151 McCarthy, J. 1977. Epistemological problems of 6 • 1r'tifici'll intellig"lnca. IJGAI-77.
  14. McDe rmott , D. 1974. Assimil'ltion of New Inform'ltion by •1 N• -1 tur'll L'lngu'lge-Un1erst'lnding System. T~ch ~t TR-241, ~IT AI Lab. L17
  15. McDermott, D. 1900. Spati. 'll Inferencoils with Ground, ~tric Formul!ls on Simple Objects. Rpt. 1TI, Y.'lle l.Jnix. Computer Science Dept.
  16. L18J Miller, G. A. snd P. Johnson-L!lir:l. 1976. lB.nguage and Perception,Cambridge, MA: H'lrvard Univ. Press - r191 Novak, G. S. 1976. Ccrnputer understanding of physics problems st'l ted in natural lll!lgusge. 'fuch. R"lpt. NL-~0. Dept. of Computer Science, Univ. of T"lxas, Austip. L20]
  17. Rie~er, C. 1975. The commonsense algorithm as a basis for computer models of human memory, inference, belief and contextu'll l11nguage comprehension. TINIAP-1, 100-1 ;1'). L21)
  18. Schank, R. c. and R. Abelson. 1977 . Scripts, Plans, Goals, and Un1ershnding. Hills:lale, NJ: Erlhl).l!l. ------- L22]
  19. Simmons, R. F. 1975. 'l'ne Clowns Microworld. _TI_N_IA--iP:,.,-,.,..1 ~ 17-9. (2~J Talmy, L. 1973. The Rel!ltion of Grsmmar to Cognition -A Synopsis. TINLAP-2, 14-24. \.241
  20. Waltz, D. L. arid L. Boggess. 1979a. Visual analog representstions for natural l'l.nguage understanding. IJCAI-79~ ~6-~4.
  21. 25J Waltz, D. L. 1979b. R9lating img_ges, concepts, and words. InN. &idler and R. &ijcsy (oos.) Reprepen?tion of ~-D Objects. Verlag, to appear. L26)
  22. W!iltz, IJ. ~1900. Underst'lniing scene descriptions as event simulations. Proc. 18th Annu'll Meetipg g_f the ACL, June, Univ. of Penn~ila., 7-12.
  23. II -waltz. D. L. 1981 • Generating an:l understanding • scene descriptions. In Joshi, Webber, and Sag (oos.), Elements of Discourse Understanding, Crunbridge Univ. Press. -----
  24. Wilks, Y. A. 1975. A preferential, psttern-seeking, sem"'lltios for natural l9.nguage inference. Artif!ci'll Intelligence 6, 1, 53-74.
  25. W1nogriia, T.-1972. Unders~~ing Natur'll LangU'lge. New York: Academic.
  26. Winograd, T. ~ Understanding Natur'l.l lB.nguage. New York: Academic.

References were extracted automatically from the PDF and may contain errors.

Welcome Future Conferences AI Journal Division IJCAI Proceedings About IJCAI IJCAI Awards